Mastic sells more than one line of vinyl siding, and the names blur together. We have put two of them on real homes: Carvedwood and Ovation. This page sets them side by side. You get the maker’s own numbers, then photos of the three houses where we installed them. We only compare lines we have actually installed.
The Short Version
Both lines come from the same maker and share a family look. Carvedwood is the thicker panel with the deeper shadow line. Ovation is the line Mastic pitches on affordability. Colors differ more than most people expect, and that is often what decides it.
Carvedwood and Ovation, Side by Side
| What Mastic lists | Carvedwood (listed as Carvedwood 44) | Ovation |
|---|---|---|
| Nominal panel thickness | .044 inch | .042 inch |
| Panel projection | 5/8 inch | 9/16 inch |
| Profiles listed | Double 4.5 inch Dutch lap, Double 4 inch, Double 5 inch, Single 8 inch smooth, Triple 3 inch smooth | Double 4.5 inch Dutch lap, Double 4 inch, Double 5 inch, Triple 3 inch brushed |
| Panel locking system | T2 Locking System | SNAP+LOCK+HOLD |
| SolarDefense deep colors | Nine, including Rock Harbor and Newport Bay | Includes Brandy Wood, Natural Slate, Newport Bay and Red Brick |
| Warranty named | VIP Limited Lifetime Warranty | VIP Limited Lifetime Warranty |
| Martin homes posted | Laurel Ave, Janesville, WI and Camelot Court, Beloit, WI | Tranquil Place, Durand, IL |
These numbers come from Mastic’s Carvedwood 44 and Ovation product pages. Real world performance also depends on how the siding is installed. Check Mastic’s warranty document for the full terms.
What the Two Lines Share
Mastic’s pages list several features on both lines. Each has its Hang-Tough formulation, which Mastic says makes panels more resistant to cracking and thermal distortion. Each has the Duranyl 5000 protection system for extra UV protection. Each has a rollover, reinforced nail hem, which Mastic says gives more precise fastening. So the real differences are the ones in the table: thickness, projection, profiles and color.
Carvedwood on Two Martin Homes
On Laurel Ave, the siding is Rock Harbor, one of Carvedwood’s SolarDefense colors. See the Laurel Ave page for the whole job.
On Camelot Court, the color is Lakeshore Fern. Mastic lists it among Carvedwood’s deep colors, but not among its SolarDefense ones. Here it sits beside red brown brick with dark shutters, and the roof was replaced in the same job. See the Camelot Court page.
Ovation on a Durand Home
The Durand home wears Ovation in Newport Bay, a deep blue that Mastic also lists with SolarDefense. White trim keeps the dark walls crisp, and a long, low roofline runs over the attached garage. This job also got a new GAF Timberline UHDZ roof in Charcoal. Read the details on the Tranquil Place page.
What the Color Lists Tell You
Here is the part that surprises people. Of the three colors above, only Newport Bay shows up in both lines on Mastic’s pages. Rock Harbor and Lakeshore Fern are listed under Carvedwood only. So if you fall for a color, check which line carries it before you fall for the line.
Mastic can change its color lists, so check its current color chart before you commit.
How to Choose Between Them
- Start with the color. If your pick lives in only one line, the choice is made.
- Look at the shadow line. A deeper panel projection throws a stronger shadow on the wall. Hold both samples in daylight and decide which you like.
- Match the profile to the house. Dutch lap gives a classic, layered look. Smooth and brushed profiles read cleaner.
- Set your budget. Ask for an estimate on each line so you can see the difference on your own house.
Questions People Ask
Is Carvedwood better than Ovation?
On paper, Carvedwood has the thicker panel and the deeper projection. That does not make it the right pick for every house. Color, profile and budget count too.
What is SolarDefense?
It is Mastic’s fade resistance technology for deep colors. It is not on every color, so ask which colors on your short list carry it.
What is a Dutch lap profile?
Dutch lap has a groove along the top of each course. The groove adds a shadow line, which gives the wall a classic, layered look.
Will the color in your photos match my house?
Not exactly. Light, weather and camera settings all change how a color looks. Check a real sample in daylight next to your roof and trim.
How do I get an estimate for either line?
Call us or book online. We look at your home, talk through both lines and give you a free estimate.
Ready to Compare on Your House?
Book a free inspection and estimate or call (815) 624-6278. Martin Exteriors has put siding on homes across Roscoe, Rockford, northern Illinois and southern Wisconsin since 2006.
